Denny had already constructed the song musically before the lyric was written. Denny’s title, “A Lover’s Concerto”, never repeated in the lyric, was inspired by both the classical style of the music and his concept for the lyric, which was to be a kind of romantic poem for lovers and which Denny later invited Sandy Linzer to collaborate on with him.
The original hit record, of which Denny was a producer, was produced independently.
In making the record, Denny recalls: “I wanted the snare to have both a full sound and an edge to the impact, but without having to whack it too hard. So the day before the session I went down to Sam Ash Music and picked up a pair of parade drumsticks with big round wooden heads over an inch in diameter that are never used for recording.
When the band was ready to go I pulled out the sticks, handed them to star drummer Buddy Saltzman and told him to try these. He looked at me like I was crazy and all of us had a good laugh. Then I told Buddy to take a few minutes, get used to the fat sticks and then let’s make a hit. I knew that if anybody could pull off what I wanted with those sticks, Buddy could.”
“The first take was fantastic. We did one more but the first was the one. Later during playbacks Buddy told me that he really caught a groove playing with the fat sticks and loved the sound of the snare and the feel of the track. I couldn’t have agreed more.”
After the record was turned down by the all he major labels and top independents as being too different (and strange), Denny finally brought it to Bob Crewe for his fledgling Dynovoice label. Denny and Bob were already working together as song collaborators and with Denny’s arrangements for The Four Seasons and others.
Denny says “Bob heard it once, got very excited and said he thought it was a smash record. So I told him that since he was the only other person who felt that way, he should release it on his label, which he did.”
The artists, a three-girl vocal group (renamed “The Toys” before the session), were originally brought to Denny (when he was searching for the right group to sing “A Lover’s Concerto”) by a friend of several years who was an aspiring talent manager.
After becoming a major hit, the Toys version was quickly followed by a number of cover recordings by R& B, pop, jazz and other artists. These included Diana Ross and the Supremes’ version (on their “I Hear A Symphony album”) and then Sarah Vaughn’s hit Mercury Records recording (produced by Quincy Jones), which again put the song on the Billboard Top 100 and introduced it to many additional radio formats and audiences.
Since then “A Lover’s Concerto”, now a worldwide standard, has continued to be recorded by various artists of many different styles.
In 1998 the song was a big hit again in Japan, Korea and China by Kelly Chen.